Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Isaiah 1 (28): And destruction shall come over rebels and sinners together, and those who forsake the Lord shall perish. כח. וְשֶׁבֶר פֹּשְׁעִים וְחַטָּאִים יַחְדָּו וְעֹזְבֵי יְהֹוָה יִכְלוּ

The translation of חַטָּאִים is sinners according to Rashi there.

Psalms 104 (35) חַטָּאִים will be destroyed from the earth and the wicked will be no more; my soul, bless the Lord. Hallelujah. לה. יִתַּמּוּ חַטָּאִים | מִן הָאָרֶץ וּרְשָׁעִים | עוֹד אֵינָם בָּרְכִי נַפְשִׁי אֶת יְהֹוָה הַלְלוּיָהּ:

When neighbours harassed Rabbi Meir and his wife Beruriah, he prayed and asked God to strike down those who are responsible. To this Beruriah responded: “Do you justify yourself because of the Psalmist’s pleas, ‘Let sins cease from the land?’ Sinners don’t have to die for sins to cease; it is sufficient that they stop sinning” Brakhot 10a

Beruriah understood that חַטָּאִים means sins and that חוטאים means sinners analogous to פֹּשְׁעִים.

How do we translate חַטָּאִים ?

share|improve this question
6  
Is it possible that she was deliberately misreading the word, in the manner of derash (as in "al tikrei ... ela ...")? –  Isaac Moses May 8 '13 at 17:50
1  
1  
Note that Chatta'im is used in parallel with Posh'im, Resha'im, and Leitzim (here mechon-mamre.org/p/pt/pt2601.htm#1) all of which are the people. So just by symmetry we should expect it to mean 'people who sin', which is AFAIK the correct grammatical understanding of the word. –  Double AA May 8 '13 at 17:56
1  
rashi on the pasuk translates it against the gemara. see my analysis: dafyummy.blogspot.com/2012/08/berachot-10a.html –  josh waxman May 8 '13 at 18:04
1  
the difference is a chataf patach under the chet (sins) vs. a full patach under the chet and a dagesh chazak in the tet (sinners). –  josh waxman May 8 '13 at 18:05
show 3 more comments

2 Answers

up vote 4 down vote accepted
  • The word "חַטָּאִים‏" (with a Patach under the Chet and a Dagesh Chazak in the Tet) means sinners. See for example Tehillim 25:8.
  • The word "חֲטָאִים‏" (with a Chataf-Patach under the Chet) means sins. See for example Kohelet 10:4.

Without punctuation the word can be read both ways. Bruria is telling R' Meir that praying for them to die is not the only option. If the verse would have read "חוטאים", there would be no other interpretation except for "sinners". Since the word is "חטאים", it could be read either way. If so, why understand it as "sinners" (and therefore pray for them to die) when you can understand it as "sin", and pray for them to do Teshuva, a much better option.

(Based on the Maharsha and The Kotev. This is why the Rashi on the Gemara has Nekudot as well.).


Bruria is therefore not saying the the word in Tehillim 104:35 actually means sins, she's saying that the possibility exists (if it wanted to be completely unambiguious it would have used the word "חוטאים"), and therefore don't be so quick to destroy what you can instead transform.

Therefore, when Rashi on the verse says that "חוטאים" == "חטאים", he is not arguing with the Gemara or Bruria.

share|improve this answer
1  
Sounds like Bruia wasn't looking at a text with Nekudot. –  Double AA Oct 23 '13 at 16:58
add comment

Most commentators I saw claim that the correct translation is sinners. It could be that Beruriah really meant to state that the end goal of a world free of sinners may also be accomplished by bringing them to correct their ways.

share|improve this answer
    
You saw some commentators who though the proper translation was Sins?? –  Double AA Jul 23 '13 at 21:26
    
Grammatically, contextually, and in other verses it means sinners. I didn't find anyone who explains like Beruriah, but perhaps there are commentators who I didn't see which explain differently. –  Ofer Livnat Jul 24 '13 at 7:01
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.