Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

In Rashi's comment to Shemos 12:22 we read

ואתם לא תצאו וגו': מגיד שמאחר שנתנה רשות למשחית לחבל אינו מבחין בין צדיק לרשע
…once permission has been given to the משחית (destroyer) to damage, it does not distinguish between a righteous and a wicked person.

however earlier in pasuk 13 Rashi cites the mechilta which states

אבל הווה הוא במצרים הרי שהיה מצרי בביתו של ישראל, יכול ימלט, תלמוד לומר ולא יהיה בכם נגף, אבל הווה במצרי שבבתיכם, הרי שהיה ישראל בביתו של מצרי, שומע אני ילקה כמותו, תלמוד לומר ולא יהיה בכם נגף
…Thus, if an Egyptian were in an Israelite's home, you'd suppose he could escape [the plague]; the verse tells us "there won't be a נגף, plague, in you" — but there will be in the Egyptian in your homes. Thus, if an Israelite were in an Egyptian's home, I'd understand he'd be smitten like him; the verse tells us "there won't be a נגף, plague, in you".

  1. Are the terms משחית and נגף equivalent? What "force" is doing the killing exactly?
  2. Can whatever agency that is performing the killing on that night differentiate between Jew and Egyptian?
  3. If it can discriminate, what is the need for the sign of the blood?
  4. Why does Rashi in pasuk 22 contrast צדיק and רשע and not Jew/Egyptian?
  5. Why is this destructive force able to differentiate between firstborn and non-firstborn of the Egyptians but nothing else?
share|improve this question
    
related article here –  Fred Feb 25 '13 at 22:20

1 Answer 1

  1. The force is G-d himself, not a Malach. Source is obviously the Pesach Haggadah:

    Ani ve lo malach. Ani ve lo saraph. etc. (#57-59). Which Rashi himself (Exodus 12:12) comments to agree with this: will

I wreak judgments-I The Lord: I by Myself and not through a messenger. — [from Passover Haggadah]
אעשה שפטים אני ה': אני בעצמי ולא על ידי שליח:

  1. G-d knows everything. Therefore He knows who is Jewish, who is Egyptian and exactly who is firstborn.

  2. The ritual performed by the Israelites is not there to show who is one of them or not, but a commandment, primarily to show their commitment to being an Eved Hashem. They are switching one Avodah for a different one.

  3. On verse 23 Rashi simply writes:

and He will not permit the destroyer: Heb. וְלֹא יִךְתֵּן, lit., and will not give. [I.e.,] He will not grant him the ability to enter, as in “but God did not permit him (נְתָנוֹ) to harm me” (Gen. 31:7)

ולא יתן המשחית: ולא יתן לו יכולת לבא, כמו (בראשית לא ז) ולא נתנו א-להים להרע עמדי:

  1. Of course G-d can distinguish but this night in particular there is a certain miracle to take place, in which, at exactly midnight, all the Egyptian firstborns will be struck dead in one moment. Therefore nobody else will die that night, even those who normally would have done by the normal force of nature. This may be the meaning of not letting the destroyer to enter... Not even to take the lives of those who normally would have died that night.
share|improve this answer
    
Not everyone agrees to your #1, eg. judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/27442/… –  Double AA Jan 19 at 15:46
    
#1 seems to contradict the first Rashi cited by the op. #3-5 seem to contradict the plain meaning of verse 12:23 –  rikitikitembo Jan 20 at 1:32

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.