Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

There are certain laws pertaining to a floor. For example, if a Sefer Torah is dropped on the floor, one is supposed to do some sort of atonement (eg., most famously, fasting for 40 days).

What is considered a floor in Halachah? Does an elevated platform have that status? What size? How about a stage - or a Bimah, for that matter? Is a car floor a floor? A bus, train, or airplane? Moving or parked?

share|improve this question
    
having difficulty tagging. –  Seth J Feb 13 '13 at 4:37
    
I'm not sure, but I think one is also supposed to do some form of penance if the dropped sefer Torah lands elsewhere as well. In other words, if you fumble and drop the sefer Torah and it falls with a thud onto a table, I'm pretty sure that you still need to fast. –  Shimon bM Feb 13 '13 at 5:19
1  
related: judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/16327/… -- and the tzitz eliezer brought in the answer discusses fasting and sefer torahs in great detail, it may address this aspect as well –  Menachem Feb 13 '13 at 5:26
    
Thanks, @menachem. –  Seth J Feb 13 '13 at 13:21
1  
Can you source your example? I believe the language there is ארץ ("ground"). In fact I want to close this as unlcear until you define the relevant Hebrew term we are seeking to understand. Certainly we will find no early sources about פלורים. –  Double AA Jul 2 at 19:28

5 Answers 5

In the Sefer Avnei Yashfei 4:109:2 was asked if a sefer Torah fell inside the Aron Kodesh does one have to fast.

He writes that one does not have to fast(there is more savoros but put in whats applicable here), the main reason being that it is not a place for walking like the Atzei HaLevanon 2:71 writes(he is quoted in previous part of tshuva regarding some of the sefer Torah fell,and some fell on a bench),He asked Rav Elyashiv and he held the fact that its not for walking it is not like falling,and he added that there are some who are even meikeil in regards to steps to the aron kodesh because its main purpose is not for regular walking.

It seems that floor means a place that is made for walking.

share|improve this answer

The Magen Avraham (44, 5) refers to the custom of fasting if a sefer torah or tefillin fall onto the ground. He does indeed use the words 'al haaretz'. (Seemingly the only difference between sefer torah or tefillin in this law is that one fasts for a sefer torah falling even if it was in its wrapping/container.) The Mishna Berura cites the Magen Avraham (40, 3.)

Piskei Teshuvot (vol 1 p.359) refers to Shut Afarkasta De'aniya that who says that this only applies if the tefillin fell onto the actual ground, however, if they fell onto a vessel that was on the ground one would not have to fast.

The Kaf Hachayim (40, 7) based upon the Ben Ish Chai does not rule that they have to fall onto the ground. If they fall more than three tefachim it is a denigration of the tefillin and one should fast/give charity. It is not important what they fell onto but rather that they fell from his hand.

According to the first opinion it is clear that something like a bimah is not considered part of the floor. At the very least it would be a vessel upon the floor.

Generally, there is a law of lavud, i.e. anything within 3 tefachim of the ground is considered part of the ground. For example, the Shulchan Aruch discusses this regarding praying on a raised area above 3 tefachim (90, 1). However, if the raised area is 4 x 4 amos wide it has a status as a separate floor (90, 2). The cases you mentioned of cars, trains and planes the floor would usually have the dimensions to be considered a floor in these regards.

share|improve this answer
    
Not sure how this answers the question. What is a "floor"? –  Double AA Jul 3 at 23:27
    
The comments on the earlier answer apply to this one, also. I don't see how this answers the question. –  msh210 Jul 3 at 23:27

I don't believe that there's a 'one size fits all' answer to the more general question of how we define a floor in halakha, but we may be able to extrapolate a few principles.

We can import a halakha from the laws of shabbos (and sukka): levud. This means that anything withing 3 tefachim is considered attached. If a step etc. is raised slightly off the ground, but less than 3 tefachim, then it is not raised enough to be considered something other than floor.

One of the only cases where the Shulchan Aruch gives some parameters for what's considered a floor is in the laws of prayer. He writes in O.C 90:2 that a person may not daven on a raised platform, but if this platform is 4 by 4 amos, then it is permissible. One reason is because a person davening on such a platform won't fall off, but another reason (see Beis Yosef in the name of Mahari Abuhav) is because an area that is 4x4 amos is considered a 'reshus bifnei atzmo', it's own domain (also from Gemara Shabbos, see daf 5a). This reasoning sounds like it would be applicable anywhere else we need to define a floor: something that is 4x4 amos is its own floor, even if it's a raised platform.

However, I'd imagine that another requirement to be a floor is that it's actually used as a floor. A table can also be 4x4 amos but is not a floor because nobody uses it as such. Especially for a halakha (not necessarily this one, just hypothetically) which depends on the disrespect that is conveyed by a floor, I'd imagine that only a platform that is made to be used primarily for being stepped on fits the bill.

share|improve this answer
    
Regarding "I'd imagine that only a platform that is made to be used primarily for being stepped on fits the bill.", see Sam's answer –  Shokhet Jul 4 at 17:33

the floor isn't relevant as far as fasting goes, one would fast no mater if the sefer Torah was dropped on the floor or on a table. As quoted from the kitzur shulchan aruch (chapter 28 paragraph 12), "If a sefer Torah falls out of someone's hand, even if it is [covered] by its mantle, he must fast, and it is the custom that those who see it [fall] also fast." Here the emphasis is on the falling and not on where the Torah fell.

share|improve this answer
5  
I don't see how this answers the question. –  msh210 Jul 3 at 5:22
    
Specifically, the question was what's considered a floor (e.g. for the rule of a sefer Tora's falling on it). You answered that if a sefer Tora falls anywhere one fasts, floor or not. That doesn't answer the question as to what's a floor. –  msh210 Jul 3 at 14:59
2  
Well, I think he's suggesting that "floor" for this purpose is not actually a floor. –  andrewmh20 Jul 3 at 16:34
    
I am fully in agreement with @msh210 on this one. The question clearly uses the falling Torah as a proof of concept that the definition of a floor is a critical one for halacha. You may take issue with this premise, but that would take the form of a comment on the question (and perhaps a suggestion of a better example). –  WAF Jul 3 at 21:48
    
Would you say if it fell but was caught before falling on anything, you should fast? That would seem to be the logical conclusion of your "diyuk" –  YeZ Jul 3 at 23:13

Most of those examples would indeed be considered a floor (with the exception of a Bimah which would be like a table). However, depending on the situation, different halachot may apply. For example, in some situations it makes a difference if the floor was carpeted etc. In other words, if heaven forbid this situation would arise and either Tefilin or a sefer Torah were to fall onto the floor, it would be best to ask a Rabbi about that specific situation.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.