Tell me more ×
Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.
up vote 0 down vote favorite

If it is prohibited for a women who want's to have children to marry a a man who had a vasectomy and the man told her before the wedding that he had the vasectomy and she had in mind to get invitro from his surgically removed sperm. Is that a valid marriage? Also the rabbi who performed the wedding was not informed of the vasectomy I am guessing how does this whole picture play in the eyes of Hashem. They are both orthodox but at the time of the vasectomy this man was not observant and had 4 children already from a previous marriage. He is a Cohen as well. Is he still a Cohen? I see there has been no bracha since they married I was wondering if this was due to the story above.

share|improve this question
There were 2 different answers in the first question "Is Cohen who had a vasectomy allowed to Bless?" to him being a Cohen that is why I ask the question again to be clear. – Penina Jan 17 at 11:40
Who wrote the second one? – Double AA♦ Jan 17 at 16:02
A kohen isn't allowed to marry a divorced woman or a woman who had to have chalitzah performed to her. Maybe that is the reason you haven't seen him doing birkas kohanim, if the woman he married had one of the above two things done to her. – b a Jan 17 at 20:48
@ba But if he is a Petzua Daka, then he might not retain the same restrictions. See my discussion here judaism.stackexchange.com/a/23171/759 (Also, note that the general prohibition of a Kohein to a Chalutza is rabbinic in nature.) – Double AA♦ Jan 18 at 6:32
That was not my Question she is permitted to the cohen She is not chalitzah and that had nothing to do with my question Only the Cohen who had a vasectomy see above the question about the status of the children coming from this union with invitro. – Penina Jan 18 at 16:49
show 2 more comments

1 Answer

up vote 0 down vote

This ia what the Rabbi Answered about marrying a man with a Vasectomy. The vasectomy procedure is done on the vas deferens (many, if not most times) inside the body cavity (as opposed to the sexual organ extremities). The person is therefore not considered a “Petzuah Dakah” of the Torah, and may marrry or remain with his wife if they had a proper orthodox marriage – (source: “Chazon Ish” E.H. 12:7). If the vasectomy was done on the outer organs, then if reconstruction surgery repairs the vasectomy damage, he may marry or remain with his wife (if he was married). If the reconstruction surgery is not successful, but the majority of the people who have the reconstruction surgery are able to procreate, then even the person who did not have successful reconstruction surgery is still allowed to marry, or remain with his wife (if they had a proper orthodox marriage) – (source: “Igrot Moshe” by R’ M.Feinstein, E.H. IV 30).

And Yes He retains his Cohen Status and can still bless and all the Kohen laws are to be followed

share|improve this answer
What does your last line refer to: if he is or is not a Petzua Daka? – Double AA♦ Jan 20 at 18:49
Which Rabbi answered? – Double AA♦ Jan 20 at 18:54
IAE we'd have to check with a medical professional, but I think most vasectomies are performed much lower on the vas deferens than the Chazon Ish contends, and would make the patient a Petzua Dakah. Perhaps medical SOP has changed in the last 80 years. – Double AA♦ Jan 20 at 18:59
@doubleaa, isn't it called a vasectomy because it's done on the vas deferens? – Seth J Jan 20 at 20:00
@SethJ I believe so. But the vas deferens is a long tube. The Chazon Ish quoted above wants to suggest (by his own innovation) that if the part of the vas deferens that is already inside the body cavity is damaged, it doesn't count as Petzua Dakah. I don't think most vasectomies cut that far up the tube as to be already in the body cavity. – Double AA♦ Jan 20 at 21:02
show 3 more comments

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.