Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

The Rambam writes in his introduction to Shemona Perakim: "kabel ha-emet mimi she-amerah - accept the truth from whoever speaks it".

Furthermore, the gemarah Chagigah 15b indicates that Rebbi Meir learned from the heretic Acher.

May one in fact learn from a heretic or suspected heretic? Please cite sources

share|improve this question
1  
Strongly related: judaism.stackexchange.com/questions/14492/… –  Isaac Moses Jan 3 '13 at 18:47
2  
Also strongly related judaism.stackexchange.com/q/14787/759 –  Double AA Jan 3 '13 at 18:54
2  
You've brought reasons why the answer would be "yes", but no evidence as to why it should be "no". What makes you think the answer would be in the negative? (i.e. why can't you answer your question with the references you provide above?) –  jake Jan 3 '13 at 21:32
    
@jake i am playing devils advocate –  user2110 Jan 4 '13 at 14:29
add comment

1 Answer

Rabbi Meir is not a good example of whether it is good or not to learn from an apostate. Although he was one of the most learned of the Tannaim, he made many tragically bad decisions in his life. Rashi brings down a tradition, in his comment to Avodah Zara 18b, that Rabbi Meir arranged the seduction of his wife by one of his pupils in order to prove the validity of the Talmudic claim that women are "light-minded." After many refusals, Beruriah finally yielded to the student's sexual advances. When she realized that her husband had set the trap for her, she hanged herself and Rabbi Meir ran away out of shame into self-imposed exile.

In another story, told at Horayos 13b to 14a, Rabbi Shimon ben Gamliel (Rebbe's grandfather) was the Nasi and Rabbi Noson was the Av Bais Din. Rabbi Meir plotted to depose Rabbi Shimon by suggesting that Rabbi Noson call on him to teach Uktzein, which he knew Rabbi Shimon had never learned. If Rabbi Shimon was effectively sandbagged, then he would be shamed and have to step down as Nasi, to be replaced by Rabbi Noson, and allowing Rabbi Meir to become the Av Bais Din. Rabbi Yaakov ben Kodshi got wind of the plot and warned Rabbi Shimon, who crammed during the night and successfully gave the lecture the next day. Rabbi Shimon expelled Rabbi Noson and Rabbi Meir from the bais midrash and instructed that any questions that those inside could not answer would be taken to the two rabbis outside. Rabbi Shimon eventually let them back in, but decreed that they be fined and that after that date, none of their subsequent teachings could be quoted in their own names, but would Rabbi Meir's statements would be cited to "Some say" and Rabbi Nosson would be cited as "Others say." Rebbe (Rabbi Yehuda HaNasi) followed this rule when he established the Mishnah.

I cannot speculate whether these shocking stories were a product of Rabbi Meir's association with Acher (Rabbi Elisha ben Avuyah), but it is clear from the story you cite in Chagigah 15b that Acher had lost his own moral compass already. There, the story is told that Rabbi Meir tried to bring Acher back to the beis midrash even though Acher stated that he had "heard from the other side" that his repentence would not be accepted. They come across a young boy and Acher either (a) butchered the boy or else (b) said that he would have killed the boy if he had a knife.

All in all, I don't think the relationship of Rabbi Meir and Acher is an appropriate case from which to learn that it is permissible to study with an apostate.

share|improve this answer
1  
Continue reading down 15b; it discusses whether or not what R' Meir did was appropriate. Varying answers there carry different implications for the rest of us. –  Fred Jan 3 '13 at 21:27
1  
This effectively challenges one of the premises of the question, but I don't think it offers an answer to the question itself. Perhaps it would be more appropriate (in condensed form) as a comment on the question. –  Isaac Moses Jan 3 '13 at 21:29
    
The story from rashi about beruriah seems of dubious authenticity, see here: eitamhenkin.wordpress.com/2011/06/14תעלומת-מעשה-דברוריא-הצעת-פיתרון/, namely the last part of the essay in a grey box, bring down an anecdote with R eliashev z'l. –  user3114 Oct 4 '13 at 15:19
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.