Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

God seems very angry with, and punishes the builders of the tower of Bavel, but it is not clear exactly what their sin was. Did they violate one of the 7 mitzvos b'nei Noach? What exactly was their sin?

share|improve this question
6  
What makes you think G-d was "angry", that His action was a punishment, or that they sinned? –  Seth J Oct 17 '12 at 14:08
add comment

5 Answers 5

http://beta.chabad.org/library/article_cdo/aid/1013006/jewish/What-Was-Up-With-the-Tower-of-Babel.htm

Talmud (Sandhedrin 109a):

In the School of Rabbi Shila it was taught that they built the tower with the intention of piercing the heavens with axes to drain all the water held therein, making it impossible for G‑d to bring another flood, should they vex Him again. (Perhaps what's meant by this is that they had embraced their understanding of science and its workings to the extent that they felt they were now able to spar with G‑d on His turf—the heavens.)

Rabbi Yirmiya bar Elazar taught that there were actually three groups; each with its own plans for the tower: One group planned to climb the tower, safely out of harm's way, should another flood come. A second camp wanted to use it as a shrine for idol worship. Yet a third group actually wanted to use it as a platform from which to battle G‑d.

Rabbi Natan, on the other hand, taught that all of them intended to serve idols.

share|improve this answer
    
Did not Hashem promise Noach not to flood the world anymore? –  Gershon Gold Oct 17 '12 at 14:05
    
see my comment to the the other answer, which essentially asks how they can be punished for intent alone. –  user1668 Oct 17 '12 at 14:16
    
@GershonGold He certainly did. I guess they didn't know/believe that - see the Maharil quoted later in the linked article. –  Michoel Oct 17 '12 at 14:19
    
@PM I'm not sure it was necessarily a punishment; they were not put to death although avodah zorah is a capital offense even for gentile - rather, it was a disruption of their plan. –  Michoel Oct 17 '12 at 23:38
add comment

Sforno suggests that we begin by understanding the motivations of these people. Why did they wish to create a single monolithic society? Sforno seems to say that the objective was to empower a single ruler over all of humanity. This would be accomplished through two steps.

  • A great capital city would be built.
  • The people would share a single religion, culture and language.

Sforno explains that Hashem opposed the creation of a universal form of idolatry. The pervasiveness of the shared religious beliefs discourages any individual from seeking an alternative theology. This is for two reasons.

  • The psychological pressure to conform to a universal theology would be tremendous.
  • Anyone challenging a universal set of beliefs would be a pariah and could not hope to find refuge anywhere. He would be hunted down and destroyed.

These factors precluded the development of a person like Avraham who would seek the truth.

In contrast, the existence of multiple religions contributes in finding Hashem. First, in a world with multiple religions, it is natural for a person to question the credibility of the various perspectives. Second, the development of multiple cultures and societies would provide the opportunity for a dissenter to find refuge. When rejected from one society, he could find refuge elsewhere. In short, the Haflagah contributed to the development of Avraham. As a result of these considerations, Hashem caused the Dispersion. This, in turn, produced a variety of cultures and religions.

ספורנו עה"ת ספר בראשית פרק יא פסוק ד (ד) ויאמרו הבה נבנה לנו עיר. זאת הית' עצת שרי הדור להמליך את נמרוד על כל המין האנושי: ומגדל וראשו בשמים ונעשה לנו שם. נעשה שם שתהיה במגדל ויצא בכל המין האנושי שם גובה מקומה וגודל עירה באופן שתחשב אלהי האלהים אצל כל בני האדם ואליה ידרשו כלם. והכונה בזה היתה שהמלך על אותה העיר ימלוך על כל המין האנושי בהיות שם דרישת כלם:

ספורנו עה"ת ספר בראשית פרק יא פסוק ו (ו) הן עם אחד. כי אמנם הבטול המפר עצות ומניא מחשבות הוא המחלוקת הקורה אם לסבת הדתות ואם לסבת הלשונות. והנה אלה היו עם אחד בענין הדת כי היו כלם מסכימים בדעת אנשי הצא"בה ועם זה היה כלם מסכימים בלשון: וזה החלם לעשות. וגם כן נמצאה לכלם עתה זאת ההתחלה שעשו בהסכמת כלם: ועתה לא יבצר מהם. אם כן אין מונע להם מהשלים כונתם ותהיה אותה עו"ג אשר יבחרו כללית לכל מין האדם ולא יפנה אחד מהם לדעת את הבורא ית' ולהבין כי יוצר הכל הוא. והפוך זה יקרה כשתהיה מחלוקת בענין האלהות כי כל אחד יחשוב שיש אלהי האלהים שכל האלוהות מסכימי' לדעתו ובו ישלם סדרם וסדר המציאו' כאמרו כי ממזרח שמש ועד מבואו גדול שמו בגוים:

share|improve this answer
    
this answer is bossing it. do you have the reference? –  Yochanan Michael May 7 at 19:17
add comment

Ralbag suggests a fascinating approach to understanding the incident. He explains that these people did not sin in any way. They were not dispersed as a punishment. Instead, they were dispersed in order to assure the preservation of humanity. Concentration of the entire human race in a single location created the possibility of sudden extinction. A localized natural disaster could destroy the entire species. Through dispersing humanity the impact of a localized natural disaster was diminished. Should a specific location experience a devastating disaster, only a portion of humanity would be destroyed. The remainder would survive. Ralbag makes another important point. He discusses the manner in which the Dispersion was brought about. Hashem awakened in families the desire to differentiate themselves. This led to the establishment of different customs and eventually completely unique languages.

See רלבג עה"ת ספר בראשית פרק יא פסוקים ב-ט

share|improve this answer
2  
interesting but hard to swallow considering it would be God who would cause/not cause any such disaster. And seeing as God didn't have such a hard time wiping out essentially the entire world just a few verses before –  user1668 Oct 17 '12 at 21:02
    
@PM Apparently according to the Ralbag the world operates under laws of nature which God set up. These laws of nature can result in a natural disaster for man. It is not God causing the disaster in a direct manner. Apparently to preserve the species God would intervene. –  RCW Oct 17 '12 at 21:27
add comment

Targum Yonasan indicates that they intended to put an Avoda Zara at the top of the tower.

סגדו ברישיה which is translated by Peirush Yonasan as בראש מגדל השתחויה לע"ז

The first Mitzva of Bnei Noach is no Avodah Zara.

Ramban Breishis 11:2 says that they were קוצצים בנטיעות which is explained as כפירה מוחלטת absolute Kfira.

share|improve this answer
    
I know we pasken for Jews that machshava rah is not mztarefes lmaaseh, not sure about bnei noach. but bottom line, they didn't yet worship, right? –  user1668 Oct 17 '12 at 13:55
    
#1 - By a non Jew Machsava Ra is Mzarefes L'Maaseh. #2 - Perhaps they did not worship this one yet, however they worshipped other ones. #3 - The fact that they attempted to build this tower showed that they felt they can fight Hashem. –  Gershon Gold Oct 17 '12 at 13:57
1  
#1 i realize, but it's unclear if that distinction exists prior to matan torah. #2 is this speculation? if not, why were they not punished immediately for that transgression? #3 is that a transgression of any of the 7 noachide laws? –  user1668 Oct 17 '12 at 14:14
add comment

I saw in a certain sefer (I don't remember the name) that they wanted to commit various types of sin like the generation of the flood, but could not do so because if they did Hashem would bring upon them a flood. (Commentaries elsewhere have explained that Hashem's promise not to bring a flood meant not to flood the whole world, but He still might flood a single place. Therefore, since they had now all gathered in one place they had a problem.)

Their solution was to build a very high tower to the heavens (ie above the height of the mountains) with an external staircase so that the entrance was on top of the tower, and this way they could sin with impunity since a flood would not affect them.

This is what the posuk means "and now (if they succeed in building this tower) nothing will be withheld from them what they plan to do (they could sin freely)".

share|improve this answer
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.