Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

The Halacha is ( אורח חיים הלכות תשעה באב סימן תק''ס סעיף ג) That since the Destruction of the Temple we may not listen to any Music. How is it that most people do listen to recordings?

share|improve this question
add comment

3 Answers

up vote 7 down vote accepted

The SHU"T MAHARSHAG(חלק ב' סימן קכ''ה) answers since people use it to rid themselves of depression it is allowed.

Reb W(V)osner the Shevet Halevi(חלק ח' סימן קכ''ז) says that a tape in his opinion is like a regular musical instrument and therfore would seem to be assur the whole year,and he says this includes Accapella as the tape itself turns into an insturment.He ends off he dosent know why but people are not carefull with it and he quotes the reasoning of the Maharshag.

The Chelkas Yackov(אורח חיים סימן ס''ד) says we are relying on the opinion of the Rashi and Tosfos(גיטין ז' א' ד"ה זמרא) where this Issur applies only in a Beis Hamishteh with wine, or as per the language of the Ramah people who are used to going to sleep with Music and waking up to music is also be problematic.

The Sefer Birurie Halacha (סימן ס)says he heard from the Divrie Yatziv another defense of the current laxity he says since in the time of the original Halacha this technology did not exsist you can not apply the Issur to it. Even if you say it is similar to the electric guitar which also did not exsist this is diffrent as it is not even similar in form, meaning there is no musician and you dont see the Physical band. A second defense or an extention is that tapes can be used for Shiurim hence it can not be a Musical Instrument but he ends off he knows theses are weak answers,and there are many ways to disprove them.

To summarize:

  1. The answer is you are deppressed and using music as treatment!?

  2. It only appplies at a Beis Hamishteh with wine (going to sleep amd waking up with music still a prpem according to this answer)

  3. New technology no Issur (halachicly a very slippery slope)

share|improve this answer
    
I think R' Moshe Feinstein addressed this question as well. –  Isaac Moses Jul 16 '10 at 11:49
2  
For an in Depth treatment (including Reb Moshe) of this topic and more on Halachaic music see here: yutorah.org/lectures/lecture.cfm/727292/Rabbi_Aharon_Kahn/… The funny part the recent desicin is 1989 –  SimchasTorah Jul 16 '10 at 18:25
add comment

According to Rabbi Yitshak Yosef in Yalkut Yosef recorded music that brings the heart closer to God has al mi lismoch. Many Ashkenaz posekim bring other Heterim.

share|improve this answer
add comment

We're just rehashing this question.

In summary:

  • Some Rishonim read the Gemara as prohibiting all music year-round; others say only music at drinking parties.
  • The Rambam, Mechaber, and R' Moshe Feinstein say it's all music.
  • For whatever reason, common practice has been to be lenient like the other Rishonim. Rabbi Welcher referred to this ruling of R' Moshe as in the spirit of "gzeira sh'ayn hatzibur yachol laamod ba", an enactment the people just couldn't withstand.
  • Common practice has been to observe the ban of Rambam/Mechaber/R' Moshe during Sefira and the Three Weeks.
  • There's much discussion as to what's covered by the ban, whenever it's in effect. R' Moshe himself included recordings, but again, some are lenient.
share|improve this answer
    
which rav moshe? –  Avraham Oct 21 '11 at 9:47
    
@Avraham, Rabbi Moshe Feinstein. –  Shalom Oct 23 '11 at 17:42
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.