Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I read that carrying between different units of a multi-family apartment might be a problem on Shabbat. I seek the general rules that will govern the following types of situations:

(To illustrate, I will use the following artificial floor plan:

Floor Plan

where: 1 is a bedroom (Jewish); 2 is a bedroom (Jewish); 3 is their common area; 4 is their kitchen; 5 is a bedroom (not Jewish); 6 is a bedroom (not Jewish); 7 is their kitchen; 8 is their common area; 9 is a shared entrance way; 10 is the outside. All rooms are totally enclosed by walls and doors.)

  1. Carrying between all Jews' apartments (1 or 2), and a common area (3).
  2. Carrying between a common area shared between Jews and non-Jews (3 into 9).
  3. Carrying between the Jewish and non-Jewish areas (3 into 8).
  4. Carrying between the non-Jewish apartments and non-Jewish common area (5 or 6 into 8).

Additionally, do the following things matter?

  • The type of common area (space, some useful space like a kitchen, laundry, what-have-you)
  • The number of people in each individual apartment
  • The level of separation between Jewish- and non-Jewish-owned areas

This appears to me to be a marr'it eyin issue (as seen from The 39 Melachot books page 1318, though other sources would be appreciated). As such, does having some sort of signage or similar device remove the prohibition?

(My understanding is that so long as it is all one totally enclosed space it is all one reshut hayachid and thus carrying would not otherwise be a problem.)

share|improve this question
    
Mod note: there are a lot of deleted comments relating to previous versions of the post. –  Double AA Sep 5 '12 at 4:23
1  
Soandos, could you copy the sources from the book that are relevant here? Google Books doesn't go that far –  b a Sep 5 '12 at 4:59
    
@ba I'll copy it when I go to minyan tomorrow (I don't have a local copy either) –  soandos Sep 5 '12 at 13:14
add comment

1 Answer

The kitchen (#4) combines 1, 2, and 3 as a de-facto eruv chatzerois. (Same for the other side.) See: http://www.yna.edu/archive/s_ask58e-04.html and http://belogski.blogspot.com/2007/07/carrying-on-shabbat-in-hotels-and.html

People who live around a courtyard and all eat at one table, even if each has his own house, do not need a Eruv, because they are like members of one household. Similarly, if several people eat in one room, each at his own table, even if each has his own room. (Shulchan Aruch Orech Chaim 370)

Between 9 and the other two residences you need an eruv chatzeiros - other than the roof over 9 (if it has one) that's the classic case where you need one. (Unless you all eat together in room 9.)

Is this a rental? If it is that may make handling the non jewish ownership easier.

I don't believe this: "My understanding is that so long as it is all one totally enclosed space it is all one reshut hayachid and thus carrying would not otherwise be a problem." is correct. An eruv chtzeriros is always over private property (reshut hayachid) - but it's private property of different people.

share|improve this answer
    
I mean that it is all the same reshut and that that reshut is a reshut haychid, not that it is many different reshuts –  soandos Sep 5 '12 at 13:03
    
If that are all owned by the same person what's the question? But no, they are rented by the person in each room right? So they are all different reshuts. It's all reshut haychid, but it's different reshut haychid's. –  Ariel Sep 6 '12 at 0:45
    
I hear what you are saying, but I do not believe that that is correct. –  soandos Sep 6 '12 at 1:07
    
Just a note that halachically rent is equivalent to own for the purposes of these halachot. –  Ariel Sep 6 '12 at 1:22
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.