Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Is there Tzar Balay Chaim for Fish?

share|improve this question

3 Answers 3

up vote 2 down vote accepted

Pischei Teshuva YD 28:10 quotes noda bihudah that TBC only applies when keeping the animal alive.

share|improve this answer
    
No one really see it anymore but when you go to a fish store they used to do these things as the fish was still Jumping around when the cut and scaled it. Plus these teshovous indicated it also: "in reference to scaling the fish while alive" and for Beis Yehuda "cut a piece of fish when it is alive" –  SimchasTorah Jun 20 '10 at 13:39
    
BTW, years ago at my grandparent's house I once saw a show that featured gross videos. One was of a Chinese family eating from a fish that was still alive. The point of this non-Torah show was to show how gross it was in that they purposely used techniques to keep the fish alive on the table while they all pulled flesh from it. It seems according to the NB that this is really tzaar baalei hayim after all. –  Yahu Jun 20 '10 at 18:43
    
And this is a common practice in certain areas of China! –  Yahu Jun 20 '10 at 18:43
    
If you do not believe me and you have a strong stomach here's a video of it: youtube.com/watch?v=ivstO1Nv0rY –  Yahu Jun 22 '10 at 3:13
1  
Your morbid description of the process seems to have a bal t'shaktzu element. (I didn't mean your description, I meant the actions of the fish eaters.) I don't think the NB would say Tzaar Baalei Chayim, though. Does this mean I won't see you at this year's crawfish boil? –  YDK Jun 23 '10 at 5:32
  • In SHU"T(questions and answers) Siach Yitchok(יור''ד סימן שפ''ז)
  • SHU"T Pikudas Elezer(סימן ס''ז)

In reference to scaling the fish while alive he answers NO.He brings a proof from a Pri Megadim in the name of the Chinuch that the reason that Schechting needs a knife with no blemishes is because of Tzar Balay Chaim and since fish do not require Shechting it must be that there is no Tzar Balay Chaim for fish.

The Beis Yehudah(ביור''ד סימן י''ג)adds his own proof that everyone says you can cut a piece of fish when it is alive and no one says it is Tzar Balay Chaim therefore it must be there is no Tzar Balay Chaim for Fish.

share|improve this answer

There is someone on the other side of this argument I will not go in Depth but just a taste.It seems the SHU"T Mishanh Halachos(חלק ו' סימן רט''ו) says there is Tzar Balay Chaim for Fish. His proof is from the Gemara in Baba Kama which says two types of fish you can not Plow or use for your wagon with them and the Chinuch (Mitzvahתק''ז )says the reason for not putting to types of animals together to ride or plow is because of Tzar Balay Chaim it must be there is Tzar Balay Chaim by fish. Another proof could be That it says in the Gemara Beitzah that you do not give fish food on Yom Tov Rashi explains because they eat roots of the underwater plants and other things in the water and the Darchei Moshe (באור''ח סימן תצ''ז)says if the are in a bowl where there is no Plants or other things to eat it would seem you are responsible to feed them on Yom Tov. It must be because of Tzar Balay Chaim thefore again it would seem there is Tzar Balay Chaim by Fish. Choose your answer and vote it up and see who wins(;

share|improve this answer
    
You just proved YDK correct twice so this answer should be a comment (albeit a long one) on YDK's answer! –  Yahu Jun 30 '10 at 1:59

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.