Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Why did Moshe have to make a Copper snake. Wouldn't it be simpler if the snakes went away? (or acted as they were before the plague)

share|improve this question
up vote 6 down vote accepted

In Likutie Torah, Parshas Chukas(61d-62b), this question is asked. The answer provided is Hashem creates nothing inherently evil,for example lets say Atheism what could possibly be good with that? the answer when someone comes for help and or charity you dont say G-d will help you, no you take it into your own hands.This point is illustrated with the copper snake there is a good Spritual source to ALL things.Moshe was telling them look upwards at the Snake look for its positive spiritual source from Hashem and recognize that the punishment was for the overall good of Klal Yisroel and when Hashem sees that you recognize this then you will be healed. (this is very much my adaption of the idea,feel free to argue if this is the intended meaning of the answer!!)

share|improve this answer
Just an addition Medrash that strengthens the point:Any Jew that was sick, and who had little time left due to the sickness, was miraculously healed completely if he was bitten by the snake and looked at the Copper Snake while thinking thoughts of teshuva! – SimchasTorah Jun 18 '10 at 3:12

I am going to add a more extensive answer trying to hit on all the underlying points of the question.First I will address Why A snake was needed to cure Klal Yisroel? The Maharal in Gur Aryeh answers that it was all about looking upwards that meaning prayer.When somthing like a snake bites a person the person becomes fearful of it. This way when you see the snake up there, and you have just been bitten by the very same thing your prayers will be alot more focused and hence Hashem will answer your Prayers.(very practical) He then explains why copper or נחשת: He explains the fact that נחש and נחשת are similar names has a significance since names indicate the essence of a thing, the נחשת heals the נחש because of their similarity.(not so practical).

The Ramban has a whole different approach. He says when Hashem does a miracle he does a miracle within a miracle. He explains this based on the Medical Science of his day that normally when you look at the thing that made you ill you will aggravate the symptoms,and make you worse off. Here Hashem showing them even though normally looking at the snake should make you worse, here I am going to make it, make you better.Another Miracle within miracle was the story of the bitter waters where a bitter tree was thrown into the bitter water and the water was sweetened again normally adding bitter to bitter makes more bitter but here a double miracle happened.[Just a note on this point today's medical science definitely does not concur with that of the Ramban's when you add an acid to a base it neutralizes-hence bitter and bitter is explained]

For the super mystically inclined;The CHIDAH in his Sefer "CHADRIE BETEN" says The reason snakes of נחשת where used is because the original snake was responsible for the early deaths of the children of נח until שת.Hence the cure was נחשת.

share|improve this answer
You mean the Ramban Miracle is now standard medical science anti-venom has snake venom in it. – YRU Jun 16 '10 at 10:34
Exactly where are these sources? – Yahu Jun 17 '10 at 14:54
The Gur Aryeh is on the Rashi about the snakes as is the Ramban and the Chida I saw in toras Chidah which is a Likut. – SimchasTorah Jun 17 '10 at 21:51

Snakes attacked the Jews that insulted the Mann, because no matter what a snake eats, it tastes like dust.Therefore, Hashem said, “Let the creature that eats many things and tastes only one thing – punish those who eat one thing and it tastes like many things.

share|improve this answer
3 answers for one question... Not bad... – yydl Jun 18 '10 at 3:07
@YS: true (Rashi says this), but that doesn't really answer the question of why the copper snake was needed - just why Hashem chose to punish them with snakebites in the first place. – Alex Jun 18 '10 at 15:06

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.