Sign up ×
Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

By putting someone on a cholim list you are asking the tzibur to daven/ say tehillim on their behalf. How sick does someone need to be for it to be appropriate to put them on such a list?

share|improve this question
mah-nishtana, welcome, and thanks for your interesting question! I hope you enjoy the site and stick around. Please consider registering your account, which will give you access to more of the site's features. – msh210 May 16 '12 at 18:47
This is surely not a halacha question, is it? You want to know about societal norms, correct? – HodofHod May 16 '12 at 19:45
@HodofHod - It may be a halachic problem to suggest that someone else is afflicted with some problem they don't actually have, lest the suggestion activate a judgment against that person (see Moed Katan 18a). – Fred May 16 '12 at 22:52
Besides praying for the sick, a person who is not sick can pray not to get sick.I have seen people make a Mi Sheberach for a person with fever. – Gershon Gold May 17 '12 at 22:22
@HodofHod, I found this question when searching before asking essentially the same thing. I wonder whether praying for someone who's "not sick enough" is (a) a bracha made in vain, (b) theft of the community's time, (c) an offense against that person (who people now think is much sicker) -- choose all that apply. – Monica Cellio Aug 24 '12 at 13:00

4 Answers 4

My late Rav, Rabbi Gedaliah Anemer, zt'l, founder and Rosh HaYeshiva of The Yeshiva of Greater Washington D.C., held that mishaberachs should not be said for those with chronic illnesses that are not life threatening at present. He said we don't want to "drey G-d's kup" (i.e. bother Him) with prayers for people who are going to have their illness for years to come. For example, he cited diseases such as MS and Parkinson's. I'm sure he was also concerned about tircha l'tzibur (a strain upon the congregation) by making them wait through a long list of names on the mishaberach list. I generally limit my contributions to my shul's mishaberach list to friends and relatives with life-threatening cancer or other life-threatening diseases such as a severe stroke.

share|improve this answer
Since when are we concerned with bothering G-d? G-d as the all-powerful doesn't get frustrated when people keep bothering Him. We have been asking for the same things every day for millenia! – LN6595 Feb 3 at 0:49
@LN6595 Perhaps the Rosh HaYeshiva was not being literal (I can't ask him now), but I've learned from other rabbis that there are limits to how sick one must be to have a mishaberach said in shul, and chronic and non-life-threatening illnesses usually don't make the cut. I would like someone with better skills than myself to research this and find out what those limits are. I'll even offer a bounty. – Bruce James Feb 3 at 14:49
@BruceJames I too am a talmid of Rav Anemer tz'l and i heard this comment from him as well, i assume from the different mekoros that i have seen, is that it is a machlokes if the mishbeirach is only for someone who is choleh sheyesh bo sakana or not, being so i believe the rosh yeshiva didn't want to add them so as not to be matriach the tzibbur – Mefaresh Feb 9 at 12:23

Could the guiding principle be Hillel's "That which is hateful to you, do not do to your neighbour"?

If you would be happy to use your precious time to daven/ say tehillim for someone with that level of illness, then it's reasonable to be put on the "the cholim list" for it.

But take care, making the Community wait (eg for a MiSheberach) is not a minor matter.

share|improve this answer
I take it that this is speculation, but I like it! – Double AA May 20 '12 at 16:11
But people may have different standards for what they would be happy to do and what they think is a burden on the tzibbur. – Monica Cellio Aug 24 '12 at 12:57
@MonicaCellio Part of the mitzva of "Veohavto le-reacho komocho" as expressed by Hillel is to know what the other's standards and wishes are. (Heard from a shiur by Rabbi R Leuchter). So to apply the principle, your comment implies that I would have to work from a judgement of the standards of the community in which I was praying. – Avrohom Yitzchok Aug 25 '12 at 22:57

Sheilas Yaavetz 64 - column starting ונ"ל טעם discussing praying for a sick person on Shabbos, says that one should only pray for a ill person, who's illness has taken a turn for the worse

לכן אין לבקש על החולה אם לא תקף עליו חליו

His basis is Tircha D'Tzibura, which as you see we do not Daven 18 Brachos in Shemona Esrei on Shabbos.

אלא משום טורח הציבור אין מתפללין בו י״ח רק ז׳ ברכות, דהיינו משום שנצטוינו לענג השבת, ושלא נאריך בו בבקשתנו כמו בחול, האי הוא טירחא דצבורא

He goes on to say that one should not pray in an individual way nor with a Mi Sheberach it is all forbidden

ולא שנא דרך כללי, או פרטי כמו שהוא הנוסח דמי שבירך , הכל אסור

However he says (this is printed over 200 years ago) we have a problem instituting this, as this has been the Minhag for a while.

אלא שאין כחנו יפה למחות מאחר שכבר נהגו משנים קדמוניות

This question and answer was specific to Shabbos. Perhaps during the week where there is more Tircha D'Tzibura (as people have to get to work) it is the same or perhaps during the week where we Daven a regular Shemona Esrei, Tircha D'Tzibura does not apply. Either way I imagine the line אלא שאין כחנו יפה למחות מאחר שכבר נהגו משנים קדמוניות would apply in the weekday too.

share|improve this answer
Does he specify a rationale? – Bruce James Feb 3 at 20:26

There is a gemara in Brachos 45b where Rava would not tell anyone the first day he was sick, so as not to ruin his mazal, on the second day he would tell his attendant to go announce his sickness so that people who love him would pray for him and so the people who hate him would be joyous which would result in Hashem having pity on him. A win win situation.

He didn't seem worried about the tircha for the people who would be praying for him.

In fact, any mitzvah along these lines of chessed such as bikur cholim, hashavas aveida, helping with a burden don't come with a clause excepting someone who finds themselves inconvenienced by the need to help.

And don't forget that lost objects getting returned with simanim was explained in the gemara as being a deal Jewish society accepted upon themselves so that today I return your object to you, and tomorrow You return mine to me. A Mishebeirach for cholim is a galgal hachozer.

share|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.