Sign up ×
Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

I'm male. Imagine I arrive at a youth hostel where I'm the only Jew. It's a big house on a quiet residential street; the house has been converted into a youth hostel. There's a male-only dorm room; across the hallway, there's also a female-only dorm room. Assume that the doors to all the dorm rooms are unlocked.

IIRC, Jewish law normally assumes that non-Jews are not "shomer negiah". And so, if I would stay the night, I think Jewish law would consider me to be the only shomer-negiah individual staying in the entire building. I'm not sure whether or not this would pose any halachic problem.

On the Sichos in English website, Rabbi Nissan Dovid Dubov briefly discusses the matter of yichud (seclusion) together with a large group of non-Jewish men and women. For example, he writes:

A woman may not ride a bus on a deserted country road even though there are many non-Jewish men and women on the bus.

Do the laws of yichud allow me to sleep in the male-only dorm room?

share|improve this question
related: –  Double AA May 4 '12 at 23:22
I don't understand why you wouldn't be able to. –  Scimonster May 28 at 8:51
@Scimonster: Fair point. I've edited the question. Now do you see why it might be forbidden? –  unforgettableid Jun 22 at 16:34

1 Answer 1

up vote 4 down vote accepted

Rabbi Nissan Dovid Dubov[1] cites the Minchas Ish and says that the hallways of a hotel are public domains. So perhaps the hallways of a youth hostel are also public domains.

But perhaps I'm wrong, or perhaps there may be other halachic problems with sleeping in a non-Jewish youth hostel. I'm not a rabbi. CYLOR.

[1] In chapter 6 note 235 of the free online version of The Laws of Yichud.

share|improve this answer
This question and answer were originally just a comment on another question. After I originally posted the comment, Menachem replied: "That's the hallways, but what about the rooms where the beds are located?" –  unforgettableid Dec 25 '12 at 22:02
@Menachem: I'm in a dorm room that contains only men. There's a public domain just outside the room. This seems analogous to being in a house full of men which opens onto a public domain. So you haven't convinced me that there's any problem with staying in a male-only dorm room in a youth hostel. –  unforgettableid Dec 25 '12 at 22:30

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.