Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Some of the songs at the end of the seder have an obvious connection to what has come before. Adir Hu is about praising God, which we've been doing all night; Eliyahu HaNavi makes sense because Eliyahu is part of the seder; Bashana Haba'ah fits with our desire to be in Eretz Yisrael next year. And then there are the two progressive songs, one about a goat and one that counts up various important things, none of them about Pesach in particular. Why were these songs chosen for the seder?

I am aware of this similar question about Echad Mi Yodea. The comments and answer there are basically "to keep busy", but that doesn't answer the question of why these songs in particular.

share|improve this question
2  
Cuz they are fun to sing and entertaining. Children (and people in general) love to memorize sequential songs such as these and recite them. –  Baal Shemot Tovot Apr 18 '12 at 2:00
    
Well, I mean, the goat is the Korban Pesah. –  Seth J Apr 18 '12 at 2:24
    
@SethJ, how do you account for the cat? –  Monica Cellio Apr 18 '12 at 14:03
    
@MonicaCellio Have you been to Israel? –  Seth J Apr 18 '12 at 14:10
2  
@MonicaCellio I think that's why the dog got so upset... –  Seth J Apr 18 '12 at 15:05
show 4 more comments

2 Answers

One interpretation is it's an allegory to the exile and the affliction of all the nations on the Jews (the goat - Yosef etc) and we end the Seder with Hashem redeeming them.

Its allegorical so there are as many interpretations as you are willing to find

share|improve this answer
add comment

Chad Gadya - Why do we sing it as the Seder?

One Jewish author from the 1800's, Yitzchak Baer Levinsohn, and subsequently the Encyclopedia Judaica, write the purpose of the song is "for the amusement of the children so that they might not fall asleep before the end of the seder."

Many rabbis take issue with this trivialization, on the basis that if it became part of the holy seder service, there must be a good reason. In addition, if the purpose is to keep the children awake, it should be sung earlier, not at the very end.

(In my humble opinion, it's not meant to be sung at the end. It's meant to be sung whenever the children stop paying attention. We only sing it at the end because it was originally printed at the end as an addendum.)

The Jewish Encyclopeida (1906) writes that song seems to be an embodiment of the idea of justice, of reward and punishment, and relative order among all the objects in Creation.

Encyclopedia Judaica writes that the traditional interpretation is one "in which the kid symbolizes the oppressed Jewish people. It was bought by the father (God) for two coins (Moses and Aaron). The devouring cat stands for Assyria; the dog is Babylon; the stick represents Persia; the fire Macedonia; the water is Rome; the ox, the Saracens; the shoḥet, the Crusaders; and the Angel of Death, the Turks who in those days ruled Palestine. The end of the song expresses the hope for messianic redemption: God destroys the foreign rulers of the Holy Land and vindicates Israel, "the only kid."

It also mentions that "other commentators have tried to interpret "Ḥad Gadya" as an allegorization of the Joseph legend or of the relationship between body and soul as reflected in Jewish mysticism," but does not expand on this. Thankfully, R' Kenneth Brander does explain.

The body and soul explanation was given by Rav Yaakov Emden (1700's, Germany). He writes that The soul is compared to a small goat. The soul is the dimension of the body that our father (God) in heaven has given us. He continues to explain that the various animals and actions are things that affect the soul. For example, the Shochet represents the destructive force that is created whn one sins. Etc. A similar interpretation is given by Rabbi Chaim Yosef David Azulai (the Chida, 1700's).

Rav Yonatan Eybeschuetz (1700's, Poland), give an explanation based on the historical saga of the Jewish people. It's similar to the one listed by the Encyclopeida Judaica, with some reinterpretations, such as the Stick being Moshe's staff, and the Water being Torah. The Vilna Gaon has a similar interpretation.

A third approach is presented by R . Moses Sofer (Hatam Sofer, 1800's Germany), which R' Brander classifies as “A Review of the Passover sacrificial laws in preparation for the Messianic Age." The goat is the Korban Pesach, and each stanza is a different halacha.

In conclusion, to quote R' Avi Weiss: "One wonders, why is this deep message written in metaphor. It may be to teach that so much in Jewish history cannot be understood as it occurs, it can only be deciphered in hindsight. And it may be that the Chad Gadya is written playfully and humorously to teach that to survive against the odds requires the ability to laugh. Our very existence is difficult to believe, and in that sense almost funny."

(Please see R' Brander's article for more information.)

Echad Mi Yodea - From what I've read, the purpose is to entertain the children. There are additional answers in this question.

share|improve this answer
    
As for why these songs, and not any other songs - Well, if we did sing different songs, you'd ask why those songs, and not these songs. In other words, not a valid question. –  Shmuel yesterday
    
Do you have a suggestion for a better song? (I'd prefer no songs at all - after חסל סידור פסח, we should just stop.) –  Shmuel yesterday
    
I don't have other songs in mind; presumably if there were a need somebody would have written some. I did note in the question that some of the songs we sing seem to make sense in context (e.g. I didn't ask "why 'Adir Hu'"), which is why these two stood out for me -- given that the other songs are "on theme", what is it about these two that I'm missing? Thanks for the interesting analysis! –  Monica Cellio yesterday
add comment

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.