Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Ashkenaz say Bameh Madlikin, and those who daven Nusach Sefard say Kegavnah... Why this distinction?

And if one is praying in a shul that does not say his Nusach, what should he do?

share|improve this question

2 Answers 2

up vote 7 down vote accepted

Various reasons are given for saying Bameh Madlikin. One is to remind people of the things that need to be done before Shabbos (including the proper wicks and oils to use); however, this is not relevant where people pray Maariv after dark anyway, as is generally the chassidic custom, and they therefore omitted it. (Aruch Hashulchan 270:2; R' Avraham Chaim Naeh, Piskei Hasiddur 129)

Also, another reason given for saying Bameh Madlikin is to prolong the services, so that people who came late won't have to catch up. Here too, when Maariv is started after dark, we assume that fewer people will be late (since they have to have stopped working before sunset); furthermore, since Nusach Sefard and Ari follow the Arizal in adding Mizmor Ledavid, half-Kaddish, and Barchu before Aleinu, then these additions serve the same purpose. (Piskei Hasiddur loc. cit.)

As for Kegavna, the custom to say it comes from various recensions of the Arizal's Siddur, so naturally again it is found in Nusach Sefard and Ari, which more-or-less follow his directives. But I don't think it was designed to replace Bameh Madlikin (though possibly it did so simply in order to keep Maariv from being too long).


As for what to say in a shul that has the opposite custom: I would think that since it's said privately anyway, there should be no problem saying whatever you usually say. (And after all, the practitioners of each custom have no "ideological" reasons against the other; chassidim are allowed to learn Mishnayos, and Litvaks are allowed to recite a section of the Zohar.)

share|improve this answer
    
Wow. That explains everything! –  yydl May 14 '10 at 22:03
2  
The only problem saying Bameh Madlikin in a shul that says Kegavnah is that you have to go at breakneck speed to finish before Barechu. –  Chanoch May 16 '10 at 17:21
    
Yeah, but you can make it up while they're saying Mizmor Ledavid. :) –  Alex May 17 '10 at 18:35
    
@Alex: not always. Sephardim say both Bameh Madlikin and Mizmor LeDavid. –  Chanoch May 17 '10 at 20:20

I want to correct and some things that appear in Alex's response above.

1) Saying/learning Bameh madlikin at the beginning of Shabbos is a minhag kadmon, an ancient minhog. That means very old, I don't know exactly, but I could see it being over one thousand years old, and maybe even a good deal longer than that. As stated above Sepharadim say it as well as Ashkenazim, so that shows you that it is not just a narrow minhog, but was the general minhog, even in places like Poland and Hungary, before the Hassidic movement.

2) Originally it was said after shmoneh esreh in maariv of Shabbos/Friday night, not before borchu. It is still recited in that part of the davening by Yekkes and Oberlanders, e.g. Khal Adas Yereim Vien Shul in Borough Park, Brooklyn, Ashkenazim from Western and Central Europe.

3)The Chayei Adam, R. Avrohom Danzig of Vilna, advocated moving it to before maariv/borchu, the logic being that then one could still fix a problem addressed in the mishnayos, if Shabbos has not started. In Lita, Eastern Europe, based on this, it was shifted to before borchu/maariv.

4) In kehillos of Western Europe, however, the old minhog of saying it later, after shmoneh esreh did not change. They did not change their tradition based on the sevara of the Chayei Adam.

5) There are various reasons for saying/learning bameh madlikin, beyond the sevara assumed by the Chayei Adam. Some say that this perek is learned/recited to stress that we do have lights on Shabbos, e.g. set up, and do not sit in the dark like the Karaites (keraim). Also, in general, there is an inyan to learn the halochos of a day on that day, so a perek of Maseches Shabbos qualifies for that.

6) To sum up, this is a one of the ancient minhogim of Friday night/Shabbos (like making kiddush in Shul), which is still maintained by those who faithfully follow the holy mesorah of Ashkenaz mesorah. Hakodosh boruch Hu should reward their faithfulness.

share|improve this answer
    
Just to give some chronological perspective, the Chayei Adam lived approximately in the time of the Vilna Gaon. He was niftar in 1810 I believe. –  Mordechai May 18 '10 at 17:47
    
Re your point 1: you're right, it is a pretty old minhag - it appears already in Siddur R' Amram Gaon (9th century). –  Alex May 18 '10 at 18:01
    
Re point 2: that's interesting, because Beis Yosef, Orach Chaim 270, says exactly the opposite: that Ashkenazim and Mustaaravim (Jews in Muslim lands) say it after Maariv, while Sefardim say it before. (Incidentally, too, he advocates the latter custom, for the same reason you mentioned in point 3. So evidently this rationale didn't originate with Chayei Adam.) –  Alex May 18 '10 at 18:05
    
@Alex It's my understanding that minhag ashkenaz was to say it after, until the Gra came and paskined like the sephardim. Like some other minhagei hagra, this one spread and superseded the original minhag nearly everywhere. –  Double AA Jun 1 '12 at 7:14

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.