Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Some Piyutim recited on Shabbath are widely (in the Ashkenazi world) sung by the congregation (usually in unison, but in some rare instances in the Ashkenazi world they are sung responsively). Among them, and I don't mean to leave any out, are Lecha Dodi on Friday night, Kel Adon in Birchoth Keriath Shema', and Ein KeLokeinu.

However, some, primarily (in my perception) Yeshivish congregations (and Yeshivoth) don't sing them, but rather recite them quietly. Sometimes the Ḥazzan will sing it and the congregation will recite it quietly after (or sometimes before) him.

Why the discrepancy?

share|improve this question
2  
+1. And some congregations will sing some such songs and not others: I know of several synagogues that sing "Kel adon" and L'cha dodi" but not "En kelokenu", for example. –  msh210 Dec 29 '11 at 18:47
1  
Most "Yeshivish" places dont sing "En kelokenu". And don't you DARE try to sing "Hodo Al Eretz V'Shamayim"! –  Mbrevda Dec 29 '11 at 19:52

1 Answer 1

A lot of it is just different styles and different focuses -- not to mention that many of the prayer tunes we take for granted now are less than 200 years old. As the modern yeshiva is about 200 years old, it's possible the yeshiva developed its own style and never got wind of some of these tunes.

In many yeshivas the view is to keep the time spent praying to a (reasonable) minimum so more time can be spent on studying.

On a more-concrete note, Rabbi Joseph Soloveichik is quoted in Nefesh HaRav as of the opinion that a hymn of praise, such as Kel Adon, achieves the sanctity of davar shebikdusha (a publicly-recited prayer service) if recited responsively. Note that the Kaddish and Kedusha have call-and-response between reciter and congregation. Thus he felt it should be said responsively. He also felt this way regarding Lecha Dodi and Adon Olam (or was it Yigdal, if I recall?). His student Rabbi Hershel Schachter questions why Lecha Dodi should be included, even if we accept R' Soloveichik's premise, as Lecha Dodi is not directly about praise of G-d.

share|improve this answer
2  
Can you quote where specifically in Nefesh HaRav? –  Adam Mosheh Dec 30 '11 at 6:17
    
@Adam, sorry I don't recall. –  Shalom Dec 30 '11 at 15:45

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.