Take the 2-minute tour ×
Mi Yodeya is a question and answer site for those who base their lives on Jewish law and tradition and anyone interested in learning more. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Is it an issue to discard a menorah that has been used for the mitzvah of Neros Chanuka?

What if the menorah is made from something not usually used for a menorah? For example,bottles, cans, potatoes, ice?

share|improve this question
    
I've seen people in yeshiva who forgot to bring a menorah from home use inverted Styrofoam cups, donuts (!), and bananas (!!!) for lack of a better alternative. –  Shokhet Nov 6 at 22:51

2 Answers 2

up vote 16 down vote accepted

Mishna B'rura to 21:1 says that once a thing used for a mitzva is no longer usable for the mitzva, it can be discarded, but should not be discarded in a degrading manner or used for a degrading purpose. He considers deliberately throwing it onto the garbage heap as an example of discarding it in a degrading manner. [I've heard recommended that such an object be put in a separate bag and then in the garbage.] [However, see comments to this answer regarding whether a m'nora is included in this category.]

[As I wrote, he only says this about something used for a mitzva and no longer usable. I conjecture that his not considering a still-usable object is simply because such things aren't generally discarded at all, but that, if bal tashchis is not an issue, the same rule will apply.]

[As Double AA notes in his answer, this does not apply to things like m'zuzos and t'filin.]

As always, for practical matters, consult your rabbi rather than relying on what you read here.

share|improve this answer
1  
Thinking some more: Do you have evidence that a Menora is ever considered Tashmishei Mitzva? The Mishna Berura is referring to a specific category of objects, not just anything that was ever used for a mitzva (eg, the plate I ate Seuda Shelishit on last week). I know I can't prove it isn't from my answer's kol vachomer (because of dayo) but I wonder... –  Double AA Dec 18 '12 at 18:51
    
Well, at least this sourceless website agrees with me. –  Double AA Dec 18 '12 at 19:27
    
@DoubleAA, good point. I'll edit the answer. –  msh210 Dec 18 '12 at 19:32

You may discard it. The gemara (Megillah 26b) states:

תנו רבנן: תשמישי מצוה - נזרקין, תשמישי קדושה - נגנזין. ואלו הן תשמישי מצוה: סוכה, לולב, שופר, ציצית. ואלו הן תשמישי קדושה: דלוסקמי ספרים, תפילין ומזוזות, ותיק של ספר תורה, ונרתיק של תפילין ורצועותיהן
Our Rabbis taught: ‘Accessories of religious observances [when disused] are to be thrown away; accessories of holiness are to be stored away. The following are accessories of religious observances: a sukkah, a lulab, a shofar, fringes. The following are accessories of holiness: large sacks for keeping scrolls of the Scripture in, tefillin and mezuzoth, a mantle for a sefer torah, and a tefillin bag and tefillin straps’. (Translation from here)

A menorah is certainly in the former category, especially considering you don't actually need a menorah as you could light candles directly on a table! (Although see discussion here.)

share|improve this answer

Your Answer

 
discard

By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.